the war ticker
old friendsfrom no rock and roll fun

No Rock & Roll Fun
No Rock colour supplement
bothsidesnow

mail us stuff



Look, it depends whether you want to deal with this at the level of humour and satire or whether you want to try and make sense of what are difficult issues.
-Tony Blair, Newsnight, 6-2-03


archives



related stuff
BBC Iraq coverage
Guardian Unlimited coverage
White House news
In These Times
NY Times Iraq
New Scientist Iraq conflict reports
Stop the War
IndyMedia - UK
Get Your War On
Google News: Latest Iraq stories
Ted Mills blog
GWBush.com
Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan
Guardian Online War Special
Comprehensive listing of anti-war sites
Russian report on intercepted communications


Powered By Blogger TM   



Friday, October 31, 2003
 
WE'RE GLAD IT'S NOT TURNING INTO ANOTHER VIETNAM: Since the more hawkish blogs had spent the run-up to the Iraq war making it clear that Iraq wasn't going to be another Vietnam, we've been wondering how they've managed to square their determination that such a thing wouldn't happen with the slightly unfortunate never-ending rumble of continued guerilla attacks on US and Western targets over the last few months. Of course, they're not being quite as honest as to say "well, who knew the bleeding-heart liberals would be right on this one?", but frantically sawing-up opinions to reformat exactly what has happened and display it as being not Vietnam-like in the least:

It's not like Vietnam because in Vietnam, there was anything up to 500 deaths a day

It's not like Vietnam because, hey, Vietnam wasn't like Vietnam

Erm... it's not like Vietnam because we have got much more accurate weapons.

And so on. The trouble is, while it's really easy to pull differences between Vietnam and Iraq out of the air - Iraq isn't in Asia; the Iraq war hasn't been the backdrop for the pilot of a TV series about Soldiers of Fortune called The A Team - it's just so much squirming. Because everybody knows what we meant by "It'll turn into another Vietnam" - the war would become a drawn-out tale of sniping, and death, and while the clash of the armies might well run the American's way, it'd prove almost impossible to stem the flow of small groups of pro-Saddam loyalists carrying out any number of handkerchief-scale attacks on Western targets.